Venue photo 1

Shelter Island House

4.5(72)
Bed & Breakfast

About

Shelter Island House blends historic charm with modern beach luxury, offering casually sophisticated rooms with spa bathrooms and local art. The seasonal pool and complimentary bikes create a relaxed atmosphere ideal for small corporate retreats or executive stays.

The inn’s intimate size and attentive service ensure a personalized experience, while its location on Shelter Island provides a peaceful setting away from the city. For larger events or multi-night groups, the nearby Boathouse venue offers over 4,000 square feet of elegant event space with sunset harbor views.

Best for

  • Boutique multi-night stays for small executive groups
  • Relaxed client retreats with poolside downtime
  • Intimate team getaways with local charm

Request a Package

Tell the venue what you're planning and they'll respond with a custom proposal within 1–2 business days.

Custom Package Request

Custom request

Not sure which package fits? Tell us about your event and the venue will work with you to build the right experience from scratch.

What's typically included

  • Space & layout
  • Food & beverage
  • AV & technology

Venue Details

Standout features

Historic 1800s architecture with modern beach flair
Architecture & Design
Historic 1800s architecture with modern beach flair
The inn combines its original 19th-century roots with chic, elegant updates that preserve historic details while offering casual sophistication and warmth. This blend creates a distinctive and intimate atmosphere.
Seasonal pool and outdoor lounge
Outdoor Amenities
Seasonal pool and outdoor lounge
A standout feature is the seasonal pool complemented by a relaxing outdoor lounge and patio area, providing a serene setting for guests to unwind and socialize in a casual-chic environment.
Luxurious, spacious rooms with spa bathrooms
Guest Rooms
Luxurious, spacious rooms with spa bathrooms
Rooms are generously sized with spa bathrooms, plush robes, and chic décor, offering guests a comfortable and upscale stay. The Osprey suite is noted as one of the most luxurious on Shelter Island.

At a glance

Rated 4.5 on Google · 72 reviews